Saturday 25 June 2016

Brexit


“I am sick to my stomach” said my long time friend Judy on the morning that the Brexit poll results went public.  And she looked so sick too as she had to sit down with the tray with our coffees on it. She was in pain. “My heart” she said as she patted her chest and tried to make light of it.  She’d been up since six am fielding calls from distraught friends, mostly young, who felt their identities and futures as Europeans had been stripped from them overnight.  

Somehow the seriousness of the situation – the possibility of the Leave vote getting the majority had not been apparent before that horrible morning.  The people who wanted to stay in Europe seemed quietly confident that sense would prevail, that the clouds of xenophobia and nostalgia for tough little Blighty who beat the Germans twice would disperse when the moment came to choose.  The strings of  fluttering Union Jacks in the High streets generated a party mood, the jubilation of a jubilee which has now taken on a bit of the flavour of a dance of death.

Losing a referendum is not like losing an election when there is wrath mixed with disappointment but no damage had been done – yet.  We consol ourselves - maybe the buggers won’t be as awful as we fear.  They may improve, who knows, especially with effective opposition. But disappointment doesn’t cut it when it comes to losing a referendum.  The damage is all done and there’s just a gun to look down the barrel of.  

A disturbing revelation is the fact that the majority of Leavers were apparently the older generation.  A bitter young woman on the radio said more or less “What right have those who won’t be here that much longer to decide for us whose lives have just begun”.  I can see her point. Having money in the bank has always conferred power, but perhaps having years in the bank should count for something too.  

I don’t know all the arguments and until recently was barely aware of Brexit let alone its ramifications.  I’m sure I’m not alone in that.  Now, though, it all seems such a ghastly mistake to let what amounts to a national fit of peak threaten the power balance of Europe creating barriers everywhere.

Enough.  I am upset like so many others here and probably everywhere else.  And England is so very beautiful at the moment. Warm sunny days, lanes with hedgerows full of flowers and little creatures.  Green grass that’s been let turn into meadows.  All so lovely and so vulnerable.  Along with the Union Jacks in the High Street here are other strings of flags. Red crosses on a white background.  I last saw one of these at a performance of Henry V being upheld by a standard bearer on the field of battle.   The flags of the rest of the United Kingdom joined it to make the sporty little number that the British flag is now.   Is that really what people want – a denuded flag, a denuded England, just cheddar and no camembert or bratwurst?

There is a petition on the go for a second referendum on the grounds that yesterday’s was almost fifty fifty to say nothing of the fact that Scotland and Northern Ireland were heavily pro Stay.  Maybe given a second chance the dice would fall differently.  Let’s hope so.

But after this no more referenda.  Just thoughtful government to take responsibility for what is to happen and voters on guard and ready  to argue if we don’t like what it says.  That arrangement makes me feel more or less safe.



1 comment:

  1. What do I say in reply? I am as shocked as anyone. I live in a London Borough that voted 70% in 30% out. And I was part of the 70%.
    Things I would say. And these are just my thoughts, with no authority other than than that of a 72 year old female who can remember the world before the common market.
    The English urban middle classes have done very well the last few years with interest rates on their mortgages so low. Most of them have nice jobs or bulwarks against disaster. They employ foreign aupairs, have continental holiday homes and Polish builders to do their UK extensions. Someone this week said they are better off now than any time since the Edwardians. They have come to regard themselves as 'The People'. Downton Abbey hasn't helped.There has developed among them perhaps an arrogance and a contempt for anyone else who wasn't as comfortably off, or simply one of them.. They, the others, would obviously do what they were advised by them the experts.
    They felt they knew best. It was obvious we needed to stay in. Everybody must see that!
    As a result they didn't bother to put their case properly. Remain v. Brexit . Remain - what a stupid slogan. How about Brit In v Brexit or anything that any mildly qualified Advertising firm could have thought up. They simply didn't engage with the general non urban population. They refused to tackle the difference between racism which is one thing and xenophobia which is another. They forgot that outside the urban areas on TV what people see is Lesbos and then the Jungle in Calais and young men trying to get through the Chunnel. They remember what happened when Angela M. welcomed all those young men.This needed to be discussed, aired and analysed not ignored.
    I have a very PC English accent as does my Aussie sister, even after at least 35 years in Oz. Mine doesn't go down well north of Manchester, nor did ours in Paramatta post office in Sydney. I too am irritated by being told what to do by officials with european accents. This is my country. How come he or she has that comfy job with the council and can tell me when I can and can't put my bins out or whatever?
    In addition, the Remainers patronised us and then tried to frighten us and finally bully us.
    There is another world where English people don't like to be told what to do. They do not regard those who are better off or better educated as better people. We are in the middle of the First World War anniversaries. 'Lions led by Donkeys' comes to mind. Any list of the dead in any parish will break the heart of any reader. They were so young and were dragged into something by leaders whose interest was simply in their numbers. It is relevant somehow.
    But we genuinely are a democracy. If you ask all the people a question you will get an answer which cannot be bought and you may not like.
    The history of England, from long before the Peasants Revolt, from Magna Carta in fact, is of people refusing to do what is expected. We have over the centuries developed a firm confidence in our right to speak out and be bloody minded if we want to. At school it was said of me 'Sarah why do you always have to be different.' Well, that is what the English have done. Assert their right to their own opinion and not be advised, bribed or bullied. They may well be a little shocked at the result.
    Though I would above all agree with someone this week who said 'If you ask a stupid question you will get a stupid answer.'
    As you say Julia, we elect people to govern. We expect them to make these decisions for us. If we don't like what they decide then next time we get rid of them.

    A footnote - I can remember when we hung murderers here in the UK. Poor Timothy Evans and Derek Bentley come to mind and the death penalty was abolished. But it is fairly universally agreed that any Yes No referendum on the subject since then would be in favour of hanging murderers. They never gave us the choice. This is what we pay them for.

    ReplyDelete